SEC Proposes Major Overhaul of Consolidated Audit Trail to Cut Costs and Enhance Oversight
The SEC Chairman has announced the need for restructuring the Consolidated Audit Trail (CAT) due to its escalating operational costs, now nearing $250 million annually, and privacy concerns. Although the SEC has made significant reforms, including a $100 million cost reduction and the removal of personal data collection, it seeks to take direct control of the CAT. The proposed changes aim to enhance governance, sustainability, and cost-effectiveness by rescinding existing rules that delegate implementation to national securities exchanges and requiring broker-dealers to report essential data directly to the SEC. This initiative aims to ensure that the CAT effectively supports market regulation while balancing investor protection and regulatory oversight. Public comments are encouraged on this draft proposal, underscoring the SEC's commitment to refining its market oversight tools.

Statement Summary
The SEC Chairman emphasizes the need to restructure the Consolidated Audit Trail (CAT) due to rising operational costs and concerns regarding privacy. Currently costing nearly $250 million annually, the CAT aims to assist in market regulation but has become burdensome for investors. Following significant reforms, including a $100 million cost reduction and the elimination of personal data collection, the SEC proposes to take direct control of the CAT. This plan involves rescinding existing rules that assign implementation to national securities exchanges and creating new requirements for SROs and broker-dealers to report essential information directly to the SEC. The proposed changes aim to enhance governance, cost-effectiveness, and sustainability of the CAT, ensuring it serves the market efficiently while balancing investor protection and regulatory oversight.
Original Statement
Seeing the Consolidated Audit Trail (CAT) up close since I became Chairman has reinforced my long-held belief that the SEC must consider restructuring it to address persistent concerns with its costs, governance, and funding, while ensuring that it reflects the realities of today’s markets. Markets have changed dramatically since the Commission last assessed the scope and sufficiency of the CAT. Meanwhile, the CAT continued to grow, its data collection created unnecessary risks to investors’ privacy, and the costs of operating the CAT ballooned to nearly $250 million a year—costs that are divvied up and passed along, one way or another, to investors. The CAT was built to help regulators oversee our markets, not to burden the investors those markets serve. That is why I directed staff to commence a comprehensive review of the CAT soon after I assumed my role as chairman.
Since then, the Commission has taken significant steps to address fundamental concerns. Through targeted exemptive relief and approved amendments to the CAT NMS Plan, the CAT’s annual operating costs have been cut by over $100 million and the reporting of personally identifiable information has been eliminated. These important reforms make the CAT leaner and less costly, but we must consider further steps.
Accordingly, the Commission issued a Concept Release, and one message from the submitted comments emerged clearly: market participants want the Commission to take greater responsibility for managing and funding the CAT. These comments, paired with detailed recommendations from staff, helped shape today’s proposal.
If adopted, the proposed rule would transition direct control of the CAT to the SEC, while ensuring the CAT’s continued operation with minimal disruption. In addition to rescinding Rule 613 of Regulation NMS, which obligated the national securities exchanges and national securities associations (SROs) to develop, implement, and maintain the CAT, the proposal would also add a new rule requiring SROs and broker-dealers to record and electronically report to the Commission or its designee substantially the same information that is currently required to be recorded and reported pursuant to Rule 613, the CAT NMS Plan, related SRO compliance rules, and related exemptive relief previously issued by the Commission.
In other words, the proposed rule would encompass the changes that we have already made towards rightsizing the CAT, including increasing its cost-effectiveness and eliminating the collection of personally identifiable information. The Commission would also plan to use funds appropriated by Congress to pay the Commission’s costs relating to use, operation, and maintenance of the CAT system.
The CAT is an important part of the Commission’s toolkit for overseeing the U.S. securities markets, providing efficient access to market data that supports regulatory efforts to administer and enforce the federal securities laws. Today’s proposal would place responsibility for that tool with the Commission—and put the CAT on a sustainable footing: accountable in its governance and disciplined in its costs, to the benefit of our markets and those who participate in them.
As always, I look forward to reviewing public comment on today’s rulemaking proposal. Thank you to the following members of the Commission staff for their diligent work:
- Division of Trading and Markets: Jamie Selway, Andrea Orr, Jon Kroeper, Richard Holley, Justin Pica, Erika M. Berg, Andrew Sherman, Cathy Lian, Sakisha Jackson, Yue Ding, Kyle Druding, Bradley Gude, and David Hsu.
- Division of Economic and Risk Analysis: Joshua White, Oliver Richard, Paul Barton, Hans Heidle, Benjamin Miller, Abdul Baten Munasib, Laura Tuttle, Shane Miller, Ilia Rainer, Caroline Schulte, Steve Hagenbuch, Lauren Moore, Samantha Croffie, and Matthew Pacino.
- Office of General Counsel: Russell McGranahan, Cynthia Ginsberg, Daniel E. Matro, Maureen A. Johansen, Elise Bruntel, Donna Chambers, Elizabeth McFadden, Tracey Sasser, and Michael Greene.